No Carrier Customizations For Nokia N900 [Update]

David Rivas, Nokia’s vice president for devices R&D, told Reuters that Nokia plans to skip operator tailoring for Linux Maemo phones like the upcoming Nokia N900. Analysts say Nokia cannot afford to do this and risks refusal of the carriers to offer the device.

Nokia N900

“Very clearly Apple, Android … are a whole lot less about providing customization to the operators and a whole lot more about providing a really cool, compelling value proposition to the end-consumer,” David Rivas, Nokia’s vice president for devices R&D, told Reuters.

“We have an opportunity, that we are going to take advantage of, with Maemo platform to play the game a little bit more along those lines than with Symbian lines,” Rivas said.

I don’t think this affects high-end consumers like me especially in the United States. I’ve never bought anything from the carrier because the Nokia phones I wanted weren’t sold by my carrier. I’ve always purchased unlocked phones, either from the the Nokia flagship stores or Amazon. However, I’m not the typical consumer.

AT&T recently sold the Nokia E71x, which was a good sign of things to come, but it had customizations that restricted certain features while also forcing people to pay a higher data plan than unlocked Nokia E71 users. The customizations may be perfectly fine to most new consumers, but certainly not those used to the freedom with unlocked phones.

Update. Official Nokia Conversations site says that this is incorrect and there are many customization points for operators.

This week, there have been a number of speculative stories suggesting that Nokia will not allow for operator customization of Maemo devices. Seems a few people are getting ahead of themselves. As we have said over the past couple of weeks, our plan with Maemo is to focus on the consumer experience – integrating applications and services from Nokia, our broad community of developers and publishers and, of course, from our operator customers. While we have not announced immediate plans to offer an operator variant for the N900, there are many customization points for operators on the N900. It would be absolutely incorrect to assume that we will not offer operators the ability to tailor future Maemo devices to suit their needs.

  • jfkcro
    This is great new for end users
  • ghostJago
    Here is a brilliant video of someone using a Nokia N900 to control an art exhibition. I think this video is really good and shows what can be done with a bit of imagination. The words are all made up of text messages from internet feeds as well.
    Direct link here:
    http://www.engadget.com/2009/09/04/video-nokia-...
  • Mark
    I hope Nokia sticks to this - maemo's big advantage is the open source community. My t-mobile 6263 won't run google maps unless I 'debrand' it. Why does t-mo think it is a good deal for me to have a crippled phone? The n900 looks like a natural replacement/upgrade for my n800 but I could go with an android phone instead.
  • gskimmel
    I think this is a good thing. Apple doesn't do it. Google Android doesn't do it. So why should Nokia neuter their phones just so the carriers can try to force their version of services down the consumers throat? Carriers should exist for the sole purpose of providing the infrastructure for mobile devices to work on. Why should they decide in what a device can and can't do? Isn't that the manufacturer's role? If carriers continue to dominate what mobile devices can do, wouldn't that slow down innovation?
  • @texrat : Why do you think that? I think it is good news. Operators never added any value...only waiting for new fw versions?
    Or am I not well informed?
  • cp3031
    Thanks for info. What carrier do you use, and what do you recommend for the N900. It seems t-mobile is the choice of many.
    Thanks,
    Charlie
  • I wonder if this will mean that we may see VOIP applications on Nokia phones. All the carriers in Ireland tend to remove many of these applications and lock them down
  • Mathias
    Did you see the "Google Talk call" button in the press photo?
    http://maemo.nokia.com/n900/image-gallery/#0

    Also Nokia's feature page explicitely mentions Skype:
    http://www.nokia.co.uk/find-products/all-phones...

    Additionally T-Mobile and Vodafone just announced special data contracts coverying VoIP (at least for Germany). So operators also seem to change their minds.
  • Mathias
    Considering the permanent talk about subsidised versions I am pretty sure that press is misinterpreting statements - by accident or for making a good headline.

    Nokia knows the business too well, that it can effort ignoring operator wishes. And now seriously: Why should mobile operators get less power to customize the device, than any other Maemo user?

    Considering the openness and customizability of the device this referenced article sounds like pure nonsense to me.
  • Ouch. Big mistake IMO.
  • Name
    I still believe nokia n900 will be a success!
  • Some people see Nokia as a luxury line of phones because it's sold for such a high price unsubsidized; others see Nokia as a cheap company because of all of the basic phones they released (especially in other markets). I think it's a good decision they are making standing their ground on the devices they make. BUT, partnering up from time to time is good for the comapny.
blog comments powered by Disqus